General Vacuum Press Questions
G1: I want to build the vacuum press. Which version should I build?
Click here for a breakdown of the various types of systems.
Or check out this link which is a chart of the systems offered at VeneerSupplies.com
(Back to top)
G2: How is vacuum measured?
In vacuum veneering, the vacuum level is usually measured in terms of inches of mercury (" of Hg).
(Back to top)
G3: Can you measure the total pounds of pressure under the platens in a vacuum bag?
The total pressure can be calculated by the vacuum pressure (in Hg) multiplied by .5. Then multiply this number by the total square inches of one platen. Therefore, if you are applying 23" of Hg to a platen that is 1'L x 2'W, the calculation is as follows:
23 x .5 x 288 = 3312 pounds of force.
For more information, see this chart.
(Back to top)
G4: What is CFM?
CFM or "cubic feet per minute" will only describe the speed at which the vacuum is created. It is a measurement of the amount of air volume that can be moved within a specified time frame. The "CFM" rating will not give you an idea as to the maximum possible vacuum pressure.
(Back to top)
G5: What if I can't pull the required vacuum within 10 minutes? And what is so important about "10 minutes" any how?
Ten minutes is the average amount of time that most users will have to get a project under vacuum pressure before the veneer glue starts to set up. If the glue starts to set up before decent pressure is on the project, the veneer may not adhere correctly.
If you can't get the pressure on the project within 10 minutes, you can use a smaller bag, a slower setting glue, chill the air in the work shop (to slow down the glue flash), or add an additional pump. Or...
You can also use a Shop-Vac to pull some of the bulk air when using exceptionally large vacuum bags. The easiest way to do it is to tee in a ball valve to the vacuum line (between the reservoir and the bag). Then you'll need to rig up a few fittings to mate the Shop-Vac hose to the vacuum line. Most Shop-Vacs will only pull about 1.75" of Hg (provided the filter is clean) but this low pressure air in your bags could be a lot of volume and waste a lot of core vacuum time by the pump. As soon as the bulk air is removed, close the ball valve, then shut off the Shop-Vac (in that order). For an idea on building this contraption, see the box below.
From a vacuum press builder in Naperville, Illinois ...
"...I started out in the tool department, with an air compressor tee and connectors (I had trouble finding them, but Coleman makes them). Then I moved to plumbing and got a ball valve and a series of adapters to go from 1/4" to 1" pipe. Finally, I ended up finding a piece that's meant for a dishwasher connection that will let me connect the whole mess to my Fein shop vac with duct tape." |
|
(Back to top)
G6: How much vacuum do I need?
For vacuum veneering, you'll need a minimum of 18" of Hg. However, the recommended pressure for most adhesives is 21" of Hg.
(Back to top)
G7: What size vacuum pump should I look for?
The critical factor is that it must be able to pull at least 18" of Hg.
There are basic rules that determine the size (or CFM) of the vacuum source needed for various projects. Check out this chart to see which system is right for you. Keep in mind, these are rough estimates.
| Project |
Minimum Requirements |
|
| 4' x 4' or less vacuum bags |
1 CFM for flat panels |
3 CFM for curved panels |
| 4' x 6' to 4' x 8' vacuum bags |
3 CFM for flat panels |
5 CFM for curved panels |
| Vacuum clamping |
.5 CFM for non-porous materials |
3 CFM for porous materials |
| Vacuum chucking on a lathe |
1 CFM for very small projects |
3 CFM for small/medium projects |
More information is also available by clicking here
(Back to top)
G8: Will quick-disconnect fittings for compressed air work with vacuum?
Unfortunately, quick-disconnect fittings will not work with negative pressure.
(Back to top)
G9: Is it safe to use PVC for the vacuum reservoirs?
This information is provided by Uni-Bell:
Yes, PVC pipe can withstand vacuum pressures. According to research conducted by Dr. R.K. Watkins at Utah State University, vacuum pressures cannot collapse PVC pipe that is exposed to normal service temperatures. In fact, quick calculations show that even under conditions of elevated operating temperatures of 100oF, the pressure required to collapse most PVC pipe is greater than atmospheric. In other words, the pipe can withstand a complete vacuum.
For more information please see this article from the Uni-Bell PVC Pipe Newsletter.
Please note, cell core PVC or any other form of plastic including ABS is not recommended for vacuum pressure. The pipe must meet ASTM D1785 or D2241 requirements.
*Uni-Bell has served the engineering, regulatory, public health and standardization communities with integrity and considerable measures of both time and resources. Whenever questions have arisen relative to PVC pipe performance, Uni-Bell members, through their Association, have responded. Pipe designers and installers have been provided with much needed research from Uni-Bell regarding pipe deflection, ultraviolet aging, tapping, cyclic surge performance, in-service durability, and safety.
Schedule 80 PVC
(Thanks to Jean-Philippe Mendes for pointing out this article)
Solid core schedule 80 PVC can also be used for vacuum pressure according to George Fischer Piping Systems. Click here to see their conclusion. The full article can be found by clicking here.
(Back to top)
G10: I have extra PVC available. Should I consider making the vacuum reservoirs larger?
Larger vacuum reservoirs will allow the system to recharge less often. However, the recharging cycles will be longer. Conventional wisdom says that the unit will last longer if it cycles on less often but the truth is that the moving components on the Mac valve and vacuum switch are rated for a hundred thousand cycles or more. So the benefit of the larger tank isn't really earth shattering.
(Back to top)
G11: Do I have to use the "dual reservoir" design or can I use a single reservoir of comparable volume?
There is no problem changing the tank design from a dual to a single reservoir design. You could also use a triple or quad reservoir design if you wish.
(Back to top)
G12: Do I have absolutely have to use a vacuum reservoir for my vacuum press?
The vacuum controller I offer can be used without a vacuum reservoir. To do this, the vacuum pressure is measured from inside the vacuum tube. You just need to make a "T" connection in the vacuum line.
However, I highly recommend using a reservoir. The vacuum reservoir serves as a buffer zone (or a backup for vacuum pressure). Without it, your system will constantly turn on and off. This will lead to premature failure of any pump. The reservoir also serves as a coarse filter. It will collect any heavy debris that come through the bag and through the air line tube.
(Back to top)
G13: Why should I buy parts and build a press when there are other companies offering similar pre-assembled units for the same amount of money? And since this pump will run continuously, how long will it last?
Despite that fact that each system achieves similar results, there is an inherent quality difference between the systems. I've seen the most of the low-tech vacuum systems in operation and they all work well but their systems consist of a generic imported vacuum pump and cheap accessories. The pumps that we (VeneerSupplies.com) offer are made in the USA and have rebuild kits that the manufacturers have promised to offer for a minimum of 10 years. In fact, Gast has been using the same filters, valves, and gaskets on their pumps since 1981!
Additionally, our press parts are all nonproprietary so you can add and modify the unit as needed. For instance, with our kit, you can build a vacuum bag in any size you want and still connect it easily to the pump system. With bags from other manufacturers, you are limited to the sizes they stock and should they ever change the bag connector design, you may not be able to add future bags if one were to go bad.
The nonproprietary parts we offer allow you to hook up additional bags with simple T-fittings found at the hardware store. This system is also easily adaptable for use with vacuum clamping and templating.
| Overall, you get the same end result with either system (ours or theirs) for about the same amount of money. Our system requires a bit of your time, but it includes heavy duty components adapted from other industries (at industrial level specs); not imported parts that were assembled trying to maintain a healthy "margin". A good example of this is in the vacuum gauge. On other systems, they use plastic dry gauges. This causes needle flutter which makes reading the gauge impossible. Our stainless steel gauge is glycerin filled so the needle doesn't flutter and you can see exactly what pressure is in the system. |
Needle Flutter
(What pressure is it reading?) |
And unlike the bare-bones kits that our competitors offer, our Excel Vacuum Press system has a fully adjustable vacuum range for delicate projects. You can dial it in for any pressure from 840 to 1750 lbs of pressure per square foot.
The truth is that we don't have the "overhead" as other companies. We ship website orders from my workshop so we don't need the high financial return from the sale of the systems and components. So what you get is a heavier duty system at the same price that can be modified and adapted as your veneering skills expand. For more information, check out this page... "Why Build A Vacuum Press"
| |
Excel Vacuum Pressing System |
. |
Generic Vacuum Press Kit |
| Pump |
Gast 1.1 CFM |
|
Unknown |
| Tubing |
1/2" O.D. double-braid reinforced vinyl |
|
5/16" O.D. vinyl |
| Filter |
High-efficiency, high-flow, pleated filter |
|
None (!) |
| Adjustable |
Yes: fully adjustable to prevent crushing and starving the glue surface |
|
No. User must use full force. |
| Pressure |
560 to 1700 lbs/sqr ft. |
|
1700 lbs/sqr ft. |
| Gauge |
Stainless steel with liquid filling |
|
Plastic |
| Bag Connection |
Brass lock-on connector |
|
Vinyl friction fit |
| Bag Included |
Several sizes of 30 gauge bags are available starting at under $40 |
|
4' x 4'
20 mil thick |
| Clamping Kit |
Available for under $25 |
|
Not available |
| Where to Buy |
VeneerSupplies.com |
|
Rockler, Woodcraft, etc. |
| Retail Price |
$296.50 |
|
$339.00 |
How long will the pump last?
The manufacturer says that if the pump were left running continuously, it would be two years before it would need to be rebuilt.
(Back to top)
G14: Are there any good books about veneering out there?
Yes! There are two exceptional books on veneering that would make great additions to a woodworking library.
The first is called the The Complete Manual of Wood Veneering by William Lincoln. It reads more like a high school text book than a "manual" but it is very thorough and well organized. It's currently out of print but it does show up on Ebay rather often.
The other book I recommend is Veneering: A Foundation Course by Mike Burton. This book was out of print and hard to find for quite a while but it was revised and published again in June of 2006. The new version includes a section on marquetry which was a great compliment to the other chapters. Mike Burton covers various forms of veneer application including vacuum pressing, iron-on veneering, and more traditional methods. The book also includes a few well designed veneering projects. One thing that I really enjoyed is the author's down to earth writing style. He writes as if he was speaking directly to you and his comments are insightful and often downright hilarious.
(Back to top)
G15: Can a vacuum press be used for flooring inlays and medallions?
Yes. I've helped several inlay and medallion craftsmen build systems for this purpose. But to be honest, I only have a rough idea as to how these specialists do their work.
They built a wooden frame, wrap it in 30 gauge vinyl sheeting and put gasket tape under the frame (attached to the vinyl). After a valve stem is attached to the center of the vinyl, they place breather mesh over the inlay so the vinyl can pull down evenly over the entire project.
Since some species of wood used for flooring are porous, air will leak into the system. If you have a cycling vacuum press such as the Project: V2 or EVS system, you can easily wire in a switch to convert it to run continuously.See FAQ E10
(Back to top)
G16: Does the vacuum valve have to be attached to the vacuum press? Can I attach it to the lock-on connector instead?
Since the threads on those fittings are the same (1/4" NPT) you can easily move the vacuum valve from the system to the lock-on connector. This requires no additional parts and simplifies the process of vacuum bagging by allowing you to open the vacuum flow from the vacuum press immediately after you connect the lock-on connector to the bag.
(Back to top)
G17: What else could I use for the reservoirs besides PVC?
There are no easy and safe answers to this question. I have seen vacuum press reservoirs made from fire extinguishers, scuba tanks, air compressor tanks, ABS plastic, aluminum tanks, and many other materials. Ultimately, the question is of safety. None of these are considered safe for vacuum unless the manufacturer specifically says so.
The only material that is scientifically proven safe for vacuum is schedule 40 or 80 solid core PVC.
(Back to top)
G18: Is it difficult to find the schedule 40 PVC for the reservoirs?
In the eastern and midwest areas of the US, schedule 40 PVC pipe can be found at most plumbing suppliers. I have heard from several west coast residents that schedule 40 PVC can only be found at "specialty" plumbing dealers.
Canada appears to have a good supply of schedule 40 PVC.
Schedule 40 PVC pipe is not available in Australia. I have been advised that the Australian equivalent is Class 12 Water Pressure Pipe. Only specialty irrigation/pipe centers handle it. It is rather expensive so consider purchasing the PVC kit from the VeneerSupplies.com website to save a few bucks.
(Back to top)
G19: Why do I have to leave the bag connected to the vacuum press after it pulls the full vacuum?
No matter what anyone says, a perfect seal on a vacuum bag is nearly impossible. One could argue this until the cows come flyin' home but the bottom line is that a bag will leak from time to time. Why?
- Sometimes the bag closure doesn't seat perfectly across the opening and needs to be repositioned.
- Sometimes the residual air pressure makes its way from the core of the substrate and platen components which reduces the pressure inside. This happens most often when there is a large project in the bag. You'll hear the vacuum system cycle off (if you have any auto-cycling system) and then turn on again for a few seconds. After that, it may not cycle again for several minutes or even hours.
- After many uses some bags develop pin holes which can be hard to find. In those cases, it's best to let the vacuum press keep the bag pressure in control.
When a leak happens, you won't know
it because there is no gauge on the bag. If the bag is connected to the system, you could easily see the pressure reading by looking at the gauge. The pressure inside the vacuum press system is the same amount of pressure inside the bag. If your vacuum press cycles on and off too frequently during a project, you know there is a leak and if you can fix it, great. But if you can't, at least the vacuum system will keep the bag under pressure until the panel is finished.
If you are still hell-bent on disconnecting the bag from the system, you can purchase tire stem caps from your local automotive store (good ones!) and attach one to your bag stem immediately after pulling the initial vacuum. But are you willing to risk a botched panel with expensive veneer for the sake of it all?
(Back to top) |